25 Years Later, We Still Remember

Amy's best friend trying to find her after the attack.

“On that terrible day, a nation became a neighborhood. All Americans became New Yorkers.”
— Governor George E. Pataki

For those of us who lived in and around New York City 25 years ago, we all have a 9/11 story. We have met so many neighbors here in Avila who have their own.

Kieran and I were both born and raised in New York. New York was home. And like so many New Yorkers, 9/11 is woven into the story of our family in ways that will never leave us.

I had recently left my position as New York City Press Secretary to Governor George Pataki after the birth of our second son, Jack. I had worked for Governor Pataki for years—first as his Communications Director in the New York State Senate, then on his campaign for Governor, and ultimately as his New York City Press Secretary.

For the first few years of Governor Pataki's administration, his New York City office was on the 57th floor of Tower Two of the World Trade Center.

The space was cavernous. Getting to my office required two separate elevator banks, security checks following  the 1993 bombing, long waits and seas of people. My office was sometimes above the clouds. On windy days, we could feel the building sway.

On that perfect September morning, I was home with a baby in my arms and a toddler at my feet, watching the Today Show. Kieran was golfing. I frantically called him. Kieran was an advisor to Governor Pataki, so after speaking with me, his next call was to the Governor.

And then reality began to set in. What on God's earth had just happened? 

We were calling family. Calling friends. Trying to find people. Praying for good news.

Kieran’s first cousin, Amy O’Doherty, was just 23 years old. It was her first job after college. She worked at Cantor Fitzgerald on the 102nd floor of the North Tower. Amy was one of 658 Cantor Fitzgerald employees who were killed that morning.

Her sister, Maura, and I went into Manhattan the next day—along with thousands of family members of the missing - each carrying a photo of someone we loved. 

I will never forget passing the hospitals and makeshift ER's prepared to receive the injured. The beds were ready. They were never used.  No one came. 

And as the hours became days, the losses kept coming.

Family. Former colleagues. A dear college friend. A friend from our wedding. My best friend’s brother. The men from my childhood friend’s firehouse. A neighbor’s son-in-law. The list went on and on. So did the horror. 

If you lived in New York, you were surrounded by loss.

Kieran and I attended 11 funerals. And for some of those we lost, there was more than one funeral or burial because not everyone was returned to their families in one piece. It is a brutal detail, but an important one. It was the reality thousands of families were forced to live with.

Every New Year’s, Amy’s sister, Maura O’Doherty Lee and her family, are with us here win Avila. She is far more than Kieran’s cousin. She is our sister, and her children are our godchildren. Our own children never knew Amy. So we tell them about her. We say her name. We keep her memory alive, as we do the memories of so many friends we lost that day.

Kieran and I have attended the 9/11 Memorial almost every year. Maybe we have missed a handful in 25 years. For reasons I still cannot completely explain, this anniversary felt almost as painful as the first.
Twenty-five years is long enough for the footage to look like another era. The clothing, the graininess of the televisions broadcasts, the taxis on the streets. Everything about those images looks so long ago now.
It doesn't feel long ago. 

 Watching it all brings back the same sickening, visceral feeling - the tightness in your chest, the punch in your stomach, the sting behind your eyes, the feeling that you might actually be physically sick. It is grief so profound that you don’t just remember it. Your body remembers it.

And perhaps that is where my old office comes back to me. After 9/11, I had nightmares about that 57th floor. I have run through my mind a thousand times what I would have done had I been sitting at my desk that morning. Which way would I have gone? How would I have tried to get out? Perhaps that is why watching those towers collapse remains one of the most horrifying things I have ever witnessed.

And my heart aches for the families who have that scab ripped off every September.
9/11 also did not end on 9/11.

More than 1,000 members of the FDNY and NYPD  - 3x the number that died on 9/11 - have now died from 9/11-related illnesses. Thousands more are sick from what they breathed at Ground Zero. Even Governor Pataki, - my dear friend, mentor and the man who led New York through those terrible days - recently revealed that he suffers from a lung condition related to his exposure at Ground Zero.

What troubles me deeply today is that an entire generation of American children has grown up with no memory of that day. 9/11 is not consistently taught in our schools. We have an obligation to teach our children exactly what happened.

On September 11, 2001, radical Islamic terrorists attacked the United States of America and murdered nearly 3,000 innocent people.

We should not be afraid to say what happened or who did it. Remembering history truthfully matters. They attacked our country, our freedoms and our way of life.

They tried to destroy us.

They failed.

But something extraordinary happened that day and in the days that followed. Americans stood together. Strangers helped strangers.  Flags appeared everywhere. Political differences seemed insignificant.
As Governor Pataki so beautifully said, “a nation became a neighborhood.”

For many years, I had real trouble looking at the Lower Manhattan skyline. I missed the towers. And I missed all that NY was and all those who had been alive when they stood tall at the tip of Manhattan. 
 Today, I see the skyline differently. 

One World Trade Center—the Freedom Tower—rises exactly 1,776 feet above Lower Manhattan. That number is no accident. It represents the year of our Declaration of Independence.

It is 1,776 feet of freedom rising from the very ground where terrorists tried to bring America to its knees.
The story of how New York rebuilt is an extraordinary one - and one I don’t believe enough people know. Governor Pataki’s new documentary, Out of the Darkness: The Rebuilding of Ground Zero After 9/11, tells that story: the enormous challenges, the difficult decisions and the determination to rebuild while creating a memorial worthy of the nearly 3,000 lives taken that day.

I encourage everyone to watch it, but especially younger Americans who have no memory of 9/11. Rebuilding Ground Zero was about far more than steel and concrete. It was about showing the world that America would rise again.

Time does not heal every wound. The body creates scar tissue, and in many ways, so does the heart. We carry those scars forever.

Twenty-five years later, we remember Amy. We remember our friends. We remember the first responders. We remember nearly 3,000 innocent lives taken on one beautiful September morning. And we remember the thousands more we have lost in the years since.

And we will never forget.

God bless New York.

And may God always bless the United States of America.