The Old Goats Turns 60!

Meet the members of Cohasset's mythical, retired men's-only club

On a summer day this July, the Cohasset Old Goats gathered for their annual picnic, as they have gathered in one form or another for 60 years. 

The picnic featured lobster rolls, plenty of conversation, a few stories worth retelling, some slightly off-color jokes, and the pleasure of seeing friends who have known one another for a long time. The Old Goats is a place where people feel at home with friends.

The group began in 1966 when six retired Cohasset men--Bob Arndt, George Benedict, Paul Blackmur, Pete Cumner, Herb Sherbrooke, and Bob James--started getting together. They missed the easy exchange of ideas and companionship that had been part of working life. Their simple answer was lunch, conversation, and one another. 

By word of mouth and invitation, the idea has endured for six decades. From the days of the first moonwalk to today’s Mars missions, the Old Goats have kept the conversation going.

Today, the Old Goats is a social group of 40 retired Cohasset men. Its purpose is to stimulate conversation and provide camaraderie. There is no professional or business requirement. Members come from all walks of life, although many have spent years contributing to Cohasset through business, civic work, the professions, and public service.

Rob Kasameyer, the current president of the Old Goats, sees that continuity in the group's shared history. "Over our 60 years, some 220 Old Goats have enjoyed sharing perspectives and friendship, and we look forward to our next 60 years," he says.

Membership is limited to 40, which helps preserve the feeling that everyone belongs at the same table. A new member must be nominated by a current member. In 2016, the group had a waiting list of about 12 men, with an expected wait of roughly three years. A place opens when a member dies, moves from Cohasset, or can no longer attend. The system is practical, but its real effect is personal: members get to know one another and keep track of one another.

The routine has changed a little over the years. In 2016, the Old Goats met on the first and third Thursdays for lunch at the Corner Stop Restaurant. Today, the group meets once a month, usually at a local country club, for lunch, conversation, and an engaging presentation. The discussion can roam from local memories to current events, but the group does not take political positions or spearhead projects. It exists purely for friendship.

The group officially celebrated its 60th anniversary on September 15 at Cohasset Golf Club, with spouses, partners, and loved ones joining in the friendship and camaraderie. The reason for the celebration is not complicated: a good idea has lasted because it still answers a real need.

Ned Tebbetts, who is 100 and has been a member for more than 30 years, puts it well: "At 100, I may be slowing down a little, but the Old Goats still give me what matters most: good friends, great companionship, and wonderful meals together. I plan to stay a member for another 20 years - then I will take it from there."

That last line brings a smile, but it also says something true about the group. The Old Goats has a way of welcoming a new member into a long-running conversation. 

Local attorney and former Cohasset selectman Kevin McCarthy, who joined this year, found just that. "Although I am one of the newer Old Goats, I have been delighted by the warmth of the group. Every meeting brings good camaraderie, friendship, and lively, informative, and interesting conversations and presentations - as well as plenty of fun! I truly look forward to our time together and hope to enjoy being part of the Old Goats for many years to come."

For the Old Goats, the lasting achievement is quiet and close to home. It is a table of friends, a regular date on the calendar, and the comfort of knowing that there will always be someone there with a story, a question, friendship, and a good word.