Three’s Company: Life with Jake, Toby, and Reese

Jake and Toby

When the Fanning family moved from Argyle to The Villages of Indian Lakes two years ago, they found more than just a peaceful neighborhood filled with trees, trails, and wildlife — they also discovered the perfect setting for their lively trio of pets: two dogs, Jake and Toby, and their spirited cat, Reese. Each one brings their own personality and quirks, making their home both full of life and laughter.

Jake, the eldest at 12, is a mixed breed with bird dog and Dalmatian roots — though you’d never know it from his behavior around water. “He might have more Dalmatian in him,” laughs his owner, Amy. “He hates rain, won’t go near a bath, and avoids water at all costs.” While many bird dogs are known for retrieving waterfowl, Jake prefers dry ground and cozy corners.

Toby, the family’s energetic seven-year-old Jack Russell Terrier, is the total opposite — full of spirit and loyalty. He was a Christmas surprise for Amy’s daughter, who was heartbroken after her best friend moved away. “He came from Craigslist,” Amy recalls, “and he turned out to be the perfect gift. He lifted her spirits and quickly became her new best friend.”

Then there’s Reese, the family’s seven-year-old Calico cat, affectionately known as “Pushy Cat.” With her brown and orange splashes of fur and her larger-than-life personality, Reese is both beautiful and persistent — especially when it comes to mealtime. “If she’s hungry, she’ll put her paws right on your face,” Amy says with a laugh. “There’s no ignoring Reese when she wants attention.”

Each pet has their own story of how they joined the family — stories that speak to love, timing, and the joy of second chances. Jake was originally a foster dog at the horse barn where Amy’s daughter took riding lessons. “We fell in love with him instantly,” she says. “He just belonged with us.”

Reese, on the other hand, was brought into the family for both comfort and safety. “When we lived in the woods in Argyle, we lost a few cats to wildlife,” Amy explains. “My daughter begged for another cat and promised she’d keep her safe indoors — and she’s kept that promise ever since.”

As for their names, each one carries a personal touch. Jake was named after the country song Feed Jake by Pirates of the Mississippi — a fitting choice for a pup who loved to eat. Toby narrowly missed being called Bentley. “He just wasn’t sophisticated enough for that name,” Amy admits, smiling. “Toby suits him better.” And Reese? Her name came from her coloring — a mix of orange and brown, just like her namesake, Reese’s Pieces.

“We fell in love with him instantly — he just belonged with us.”

Their personalities shine in everyday life. Jake, the senior statesman, keeps things calm and steady (unless there’s thunder). He’s terrified of storms and will shake or hide in his bed until the skies clear. Toby, meanwhile, is all energy — famous for his “zoomies” and his endearing little hop, caused by a sensitive tendon in his back leg. “It doesn’t slow him down at all,” Amy says. “When he runs, you’d never know.”

Both dogs love chew sticks and come running at the word “Chew,” while Reese spends her time happily sharpening her claws on her scratching post.

One memory stands out for Amy — a moment that reminded her just how strong the bond between humans and pets can be. Last summer, during a trip to the Texas Hill Country, flash floods struck unexpectedly. “Toby had on his harness, thank goodness,” Amy recalls. “We were able to grab him quickly and get to safety. When we reached dry ground, he sat right next to me, calm as ever, keeping me warm. He never panicked.”

Today, Jake, Toby, and Reese are living their best lives in Indian Lakes. The dogs light up at the word “Walk,” eager to explore the neighborhood trails, while Reese enjoys short supervised visits to the screened porch — her way of safely watching the world.

For Amy and her family, their pets are more than companions — they’re constant reminders of love, loyalty, and everyday joy. “They’ve been with us through so many chapters,” she says. “Each one has their own personality, their own story, and they make our house feel like home.”