The story of Red Tail is one of vision, strategic land acquisition, and careful community planning—transforming more than 500 acres of open land into one of Northeast Ohio’s most distinctive golf course communities.

The development of Red Tail began with the purchase of 420 acres from the Gund brothers, then owners of the Cleveland Cavaliers. An additional significant parcel—89 acres—was secured from former Cleveland Browns legend Gene Hickerson and his business partner. The remaining acreage, ultimately bringing the total to roughly 530, was assembled from smaller perimeter parcels that often included existing homes.

These acquisitions laid the groundwork for what would become a thoughtfully designed residential and recreational community anchored by a championship golf course.

The first homes in Red Tail were constructed in 1997, lining both the north and south sides of Jaycox Road near what is now the community’s main entrance. Architectural Concepts, Sunset Builders, Surest Homes, Bennett Builders, Continental Builders, Petros Homes, Latina Builders, and Bob Corna Custom Homes (known for the Villamoura section) were among the inaugural homebuilders contributing to Red Tail’s architectural character.

Expansion continued steadily, and by 2004–2005, new residential construction began east of Lear Nagel Road, broadening the community's footprint and appeal.

Central to Red Tail’s identity is its golf course, designed by renowned architect Robert Von Hagge. Construction began with what is now the back nine, and when the course partially opened in 1998, today’s Hole 10 initially served as the first tee. The full 18-hole layout was completed and opened for play in 2000, elevating Red Tail’s reputation as both a residential and golf destination.

Professional leadership during these formative years came from Bryan Huff, who served as the community’s first golf professional from 1998 to 2005.

Before the permanent clubhouse stood as a landmark of the property, life at Red Tail revolved around a practical but modest setup. A double-wide trailer served as the temporary clubhouse, accompanied by a second trailer functioning as the sales center for homes and memberships. Despite limited space, the team secured a liquor license and offered basic food and beverage service to early residents and golfers.

The long-awaited clubhouse—completed in 2000—not only fulfilled the community’s needs but also captured national attention, earning multiple design awards for its architecture and amenities.

Red Tail’s commitment to cultivating a vibrant residential lifestyle extended beyond golf. By 2001–2002, the community added its pool and tennis courts, further enhancing recreational options for residents and guests.

Throughout its development, Red Tail garnered significant media attention. Publications such as Crain’s Cleveland Business, The Plain Dealer, The Lorain Journal, The Chronicle-Telegram, and The Sun newspapers covered the project extensively between 1998 and 2000, spotlighting its progress and the growing anticipation surrounding the new golf community.