McClellan Park: More Than a Century of History and Community
Two visionary sisters transformed 56 acres of Sarasota into a neighborhood where winding streets, natural beauty and lasting friendships continue to define the community.
Once upon a time, two unmarried sisters looked at 56 acres south of downtown Sarasota and thought, “Why not build a neighborhood?” And that is exactly what they did, bringing curves, canopies and community to one of Sarasota’s most distinctive neighborhoods.
Around 1910, Katherine E. and Daisietta “Daisy” McClellan began spending time in Sarasota. The unmarried sisters, originally from Northampton, Massachusetts, had real estate in their blood. Their father, Dr. Ezra McClellan, had developed property in New York’s Saranac Lake region. Daisy had also survived tuberculosis, making Sarasota’s warm climate particularly appealing.
The sisters pooled their resources and acquired approximately 56 acres at the southern end of Orange Avenue, envisioning something quite different from the traditional subdivisions of the time.
Sarasota’s Original “Garden Spot”
Katherine, a professional photographer and the official photographer for Smith College, brought an artistic eye to the project. Working with landscape architects, she designed a neighborhood that followed the natural contours of the land rather than imposing a rigid grid.
The result was McClellan Park, marketed in 1916 as Sarasota’s “Garden Spot.” Its curving streets were designed to orient lots toward Sarasota Bay, while paved sidewalks, shade trees and flowering shrubs added elegance. The sisters also planned for modern conveniences, including water from artesian wells, telephone service and electricity, remarkably forward-thinking amenities for the time.
A Little History Underfoot
The sisters incorporated the property’s Native American history into their plans. An Indigenous mound, or midden, influenced the development, while Seminole words inspired street names and the yacht basin. Today, names such as Seminole, Wewa and Mietaw remind residents that the neighborhood’s history extends far beyond its homes.
And the McClellans weren’t content simply to sell lots.
They created a yacht basin, recreational spaces for tennis, croquet and swimming, and a pecky cypress clubhouse that became a gathering place for lunches, afternoon teas and weekend dances.
Croquet, a yacht basin, afternoon tea and weekend dances? One could argue the McClellans had already figured out the Sarasota lifestyle!
Not Everything Went According to Plan
Despite their vision, developing a neighborhood proved challenging. The initial development struggled financially, and lots originally priced between $800 and $2,500 eventually dropped to approximately $450 to $900. The sisters ultimately transferred the property to another developer and pursued other ventures.
The neighborhood, however, had staying power. Despite the Florida land boom and its collapse, McClellan Park continued to evolve, with much of its residential development occurring after World War II.
The original clubhouse eventually became the McClellan Park School, which opened in 1932 and operated under various owners for approximately 70 years.
Where the Sisters’ Vision Lives On
Walk through McClellan Park today, and the sisters’ original vision remains remarkably easy to see.
Winding streets curve beneath mature trees, while an eclectic collection of architecture gives the neighborhood its distinctive character. Early bungalows and Craftsman-style homes stand alongside Spanish, Mediterranean and Tudor Revival designs, with newer residences blending into the community.
And then there is the location.
Tucked just south of downtown Sarasota and practically next door to Southside Village, McClellan Park offers easy access to restaurants, shops and neighborhood gathering spots. A pedestrian path provides a convenient connection to the Village, reinforcing the walkable lifestyle the sisters envisioned.
Perhaps that explains why McClellan Park has something many neighborhoods spend years trying to create: a genuine sense of community.
In 2016, the neighborhood celebrated its centennial, marking 100 years since the sisters’ “Garden Spot” officially opened in March 1916. More than a century later, residents continue to enjoy the qualities Katherine and Daisy envisioned: beautiful streets, gracious homes, convenient connections and opportunities for neighbors to come together.
Its neighborhood motto says it beautifully: “A Forest of Friends.”
The trees have grown, the houses have changed, and Sarasota has transformed around it. Yet the sisters’ original vision remains remarkably intact.
Katherine and Daisy saw more than lots for sale. They imagined a place where people could live, gather, stroll, play and build lasting friendships.
Perhaps the greatest tribute to their brilliant design is that once people make McClellan Park their home, they rarely want to leave.