Your Neighbors Have You Covered
Greg and Stacey Fay have built a family business around protecting yours.
When Greg Fay and Stacey Hinkle-Fay founded Greg Fay Insurance, they did not just build an insurance agency; they built a family legacy.
Greg and Stacey have called Centerville—and specifically the Yankee Trace neighborhood—home since 1999. Between them, they have six children, and together, they have coached youth sports, served their church, supported local charities, and built a business that now spans seven locations throughout Ohio. For the Fays, this community is more than a market. It is home.
A veteran of the United States Army, Greg served six years in air defense artillery and maintenance management before receiving an honorable discharge in 1990. After his service, he built a career in business operations and financial services, rising to Regional Director of Operations before becoming an award-winning agency principal with Farmers Insurance. He eventually made the leap to independence, founding Greg Fay Insurance alongside his wife and co-founder.
What makes Greg Fay Insurance truly special is that it is a genuine family business. Stacey serves as co-founder and agent, and stepson Josh Hinkle, son-in-law Michael Jividen, and son Zach Hinkle are all agents within the family of locations. When you call, you are likely speaking with someone who shares a last name with the founder.
The agency spans Centerville, Dayton, Liberty Township, Miamisburg, Northwood, Pickerington, and Bethel Township and represents a wide range of trusted insurance carriers. Because Greg Fay Insurance is an independent agency, clients benefit from having their coverage shopped across multiple providers, ensuring the best possible protection at a competitive rate. From auto and home to life, renters, and business insurance, the team handles everything with the personal attention you cannot get from an 800 number or an offshore call center.
What also sets this agency apart is the depth of its military roots. Greg Fay Insurance is home to three agents who are proud veterans of the U.S. Armed Forces, with service across both the Army and the Air Force. That sense of duty and commitment to showing up for others is the agency's operating philosophy, lived out every day.
Greg's investment in the community goes well beyond insurance. He has served as a head coach for more than 20 youth sports teams in Centerville, sits on the Board of Directors for the Centerville Noon Optimist Club—the third-largest Optimist Club in the world—and founded the "Centerville Community – Hosted by Greg Fay Insurance" Facebook group, now used by local schools, nonprofits, and government organizations to connect neighbors. He is also the host of the Ohio Business Spotlight podcast, with nearly 100 episodes spotlighting local Ohio businesses weekly because Greg believes strong communities are built on strong local businesses.
At Greg Fay Insurance, insurance is personal. It always has been, and for Yankee Trace neighbors, it always will be.
To learn more or request a free quote, visit gregfayinsurance.com or call 937-619-9705.